|Letter from Representative Betty McCollum to the US Department of State
United States House of Representatives
July 8, 2008
The Honorable Condoleezza Rice
Secretary of State
U.S. Department of State
2201 C Street, NW
Washington, D.C. 20520
Dear Secretary Rice:
It has come to my attention that Mr. Narendra Modi, Chief Minister of the state of
Gujarat, India has been invited to attend and speak at the World Gujarati Congress,
scheduled to take place August 29-31, 2008, in Edison, New Jersey. As a result of this
invitation Mr. Modi may be seeking a visa to enter the U.S. In light of Mr. Modils long
documented record of violations of religious freedom in India, I am writing to urge the
Department of State to deny Mr. Modi a visa to enter the U.S.
As you know, Mr. Narendra Modi was Chief Minister of Gujarat during the 2002 riots
that resulted in the deaths of over 2,000 lndian Muslims and non-Hindus and the rape,
gang rape, and molestation of hundreds of Muslim women. In 2003, the lndian Supreme
Court found that the state government of Gujarat, led by Mr. Modi, had actively
supported the anti-Muslim violence and ordered the police not to interfere. This grave
violation of the freedom of India's religious minorities is simply intolerable and puts Mr.
Modi in severe breach of the International Religious Freedom Act.
In 2005, under your leadership, the Department of State appropriately denied Mr. Modi
a visa on the basis that any foreign government official responsible for 'particularly
severe violations' of religious freedom is inadmissible under the U.S. Immigration and
Since 2005, Chief Minister Narendra Modi has continued to violate the religious freedom
of not only Indian Muslims, but also Christians. Mr. Modi has used state police forces to
routinely beat Christian pastors and priests and to conduct extra-judicial killings of
Muslim youth. In addition, Mr. Modi has interfered with the safe return of more than
100,000 people displaced from the 2002 riots.
Given the continuing violations of religious freedom in India, Narendra Modi should once
again be denied admission to the U.S. under the provisions of the International
Religious Freedom Act. Granting a visa to Narendra Modi would be contradictory to
international law and would only serve to validate the Chief Minister's abhorrent policies
Maintaining an open and vibrant diplomatic, economic, and military relationship between
the U.S. and lndia must be a continued foreign policy priority for Congress and the
Executive Branch. Therefore I want to be clear that this letter is solely directed at Mr.
Modi and not in any way directed at the Indian Government, the BJP as a political
institution, or the Gujaratis community in lndia or the U.S. The Gujaratis community in
the U.S. should be commended for their contributions to the U.S. and for supporting a
strong U.S.-India relationship.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Member of Congress
URL: Press Release, Signed Letter to Condoleeza Rice (PDF)